Skip to main content
    Astris Law S IconAstris Law
    ← Back to Articles|Property →
    Insights18 November 2026•10 min read

    Exercising a Lease Option in Queensland: Why Notices Fail and What Follows

    Summary

    For tenants and landlords under a Queensland commercial or retail shop lease, how strictly an option to renew is enforced, why notices served on time still fail, where the rent for the further term comes from and what follows a missed date, with three cases from licensed, franchised and guaranteed tenancies.

    Last reviewed ·Reviewed by Jamie Nuich, Legal Practitioner Director

    Key Takeaways

    • A notice that is late or conditional does not exercise the option and equity will not extend the time for it. One served in a way a mandatory notices clause does not allow may fail as well.
    • Under the Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld) the landlord under a retail shop lease must give written notice of the option date between two and six months before it. Failing to do so is an offence, but in Queensland it does not extend the option date.
    • Subject to exceptions, a tenant under a retail shop lease whose new rent is to be current market rent can have it determined early by written notice given inside a statutory window before the option date. The last day for exercise then becomes 21 days after the tenant receives written notice of the figure.
    • Under the Property Law Act 2023 (Qld), whether the lease was signed before or after that Act commenced on 1 August 2025, a landlord that wants to refuse renewal because of the tenant's breach must give a breach notice in the approved form within 10 business days of receiving the option notice or of a later breach and the tenant then has one month to seek relief from the Supreme Court.
    • Serving the notice or missing the date, can matter beyond the tenancy, for example to a hotel's liquor licence granted for the premises, to a franchisee trading under a franchisor's head lease and to a director who guaranteed the lease and has since sold her shares.
    A fitted-out commercial tenancy ready to open for trade

    An option to renew gives the tenant a further term only if every condition in the clause is met, including the way and the date it sets for the notice and the Queensland Court of Appeal applies those conditions strictly. For a retail shop the Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld) (RSLA) adds a landlord notice obligation and a landlord's failure to give that notice does not move the date. Astris Law in Brisbane acts for tenants and landlords on option notices. Where the premises carry a liquor licence, sit under a franchisor's head lease or are backed by a director's guarantee, more than the tenancy can turn on the notice.

    How strict are the courts about the option clause?

    An option binds the landlord only if the tenant does exactly what the clause requires within the time allowed. A late notice exercises nothing and equity does not extend the time for exercising an option.

    In Replay Australia Pty Ltd v NightOwl Properties Pty Ltd [2023] QCA 76, decided under the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) (PLA 1974), the tenant gave notice in time, but the option was also conditional on there being no unremedied breach when notice was given or at any time up to expiry and the tenant had substantial and long-outstanding rent arrears. Every condition had to be met and, the lease having expired, there was nothing for equitable relief to attach to.

    Does the landlord have to warn me the option date is coming?

    Only a retail shop lease carries a statutory warning and the RSLA reaches a lease of a retail shop as the Act defines it. Section 5A excludes some leases altogether, including a lease of a retail shop with a floor area of more than 1,000 square metres and our guide to retail tenancy disputes covers what else the Act does.

    For a lease the Act covers, s 46 requires the landlord to give written notice of the option date at least two months and not more than six months, before it; failing to do so is an offence. The notice goes to the landlord's own tenant, which under a franchisor's head lease is the franchisor, not the franchisee behind the counter.

    In Queensland the landlord's failure does not extend the option date and the extension in s 46AA applies only where the lease has no option at all. A tenant whose landlord gave no notice is left with arguments, such as estoppel or misleading conduct, that rest on what the landlord said and did, so diarise the date yourself.

    Why do notices served on time still fail?

    A notice can reach the landlord inside the window and still exercise nothing, because the option clause and the notices clause, not the tenant's intention, decide what counts.

    In Kegran Pty Ltd v Warrik Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 1357, a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, an email was a valid exercise because the lease's notices clause was permissive rather than mandatory. A clause that says notices "must" be served in a stated way may produce the opposite result and a Queensland court is not bound by that decision.

    A notice signed by a related company or a franchisee rather than the tenant named in the lease or one that offers to renew "subject to agreement on the rent", can fail on that ground alone, however clearly the tenant meant to renew.

    What rent will I pay in the further term?

    The lease sets the basis and under the RSLA a market rent the parties cannot agree is settled by a specialist retail valuer appointed under the Act (ss 28 and 29), a process our guide to rent review disputes describes. Under s 27A, subject to the exceptions it contains, the tenant can require the market rent to be determined before committing. The request is made by written notice given three to six months before the option date (one to three months for a lease of a year or less) and the last day for exercise then becomes 21 days after the tenant receives written notice of the figure, in place of the date in the lease.

    What happens if the date passes?

    After the date the option cannot be revived, so what matters is what the tenant's continued occupation amounts to. If the tenant stays on with consent, a holding over clause commonly turns the arrangement into a monthly tenancy on the lease terms, which either side can end on the notice the clause states, often one month; without such a clause the position depends on the Property Law Act 2023 (Qld) (PLA 2023) and on how rent has been accepted. The lease and the bank guarantee's own terms decide whether the guarantee covers a period of holding over. The make good clause fixes when make good falls due, usually at the end of the occupation and our guide to make good disputes at lease end covers what that involves.

    Where does the landlord stand?

    A validly exercised option binds the landlord to grant the further term and the tenant's remedy for refusal is specific performance or damages, the remedies discussed in our guide to commercial lease disputes in Queensland. A landlord that wants to rely on the tenant's breach to refuse renewal must first comply with s 164 of the PLA 2023. It may refuse on that ground only if it gives a breach notice in the approved form, Form 8, within 10 business days after receiving the option notice (or after a later breach). The tenant then has one month to apply to the Supreme Court for relief under s 166. Those provisions replaced the corresponding rule in the PLA 1974 on 1 August 2025 and the PLA 2023 applies them to a lease whether it was entered into before or after that date.

    When does the option decide more than the lease?

    In each of the cases below a second document is tied to the premises or to the lease and it is read under its own rules rather than the option clause.

    A hotel and its liquor licence

    A company that has run a hotel with gaming machines from leased premises for ten years loses its option through a late notice. Its liquor licence was granted for those premises and s 113 of the Liquor Act 1992 (Qld) lets the owner, lessee or mortgagee of licensed premises (here the landlord) apply in its own right to the Commissioner for Liquor and Gaming to transfer the licence in the circumstances the section sets out, which include the lawful termination of the licensee's lease or other right to occupy. Whether a term that simply runs out has been terminated in that sense and what becomes of the hotel's gaming machine operating authorities under the Gaming Machine Act 1991 (Qld), turn on the words of both Acts, the licence and the lease.

    A franchised shop

    A franchisee runs a food outlet in a Brisbane shopping centre under a licence to occupy from the franchisor, which holds the head lease. The option is the franchisor's to exercise or let go. The franchise agreement runs to its own end date, which can fall months before or after the lease's and it answers to the Franchising Code of Conduct (Cth) and the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. Where the franchisee holds the lease instead, exercising the option can bind it to the premises for longer than its franchise agreement lets it trade under the brand.

    A guarantor who has since sold her shares

    Two directors guaranteed their company's lease of a suburban gym and in year three one sold her shares to the other. A share sale leaves the lease with the company and does not of itself end her guarantee, which is a separate contract, so unless the landlord released her she may still be a guarantor when the company exercises its option. Her guarantee reaches the further term only if its words carry it there and unclear words are read in her favour (Ankar Pty Ltd v National Westminster Finance (Australia) Ltd (1987) 162 CLR 549). If the lease also calls on the guarantors to sign a guarantee for the further term, the way that clause is framed decides whether her refusal puts the exercise at risk.

    When does your own lease change the answer?

    Which of these traps is live in a given lease cannot be seen from outside it. The answer is in the option clause, the notices clause and each variation signed since. It is also in any other document that hangs on the lease and those documents are often drafted years apart by different hands. If the window is open or you cannot tell whether it has opened, call Jamie Nuich at Astris Law on (07) 3519 5616.

    What happens next

    1. Gather the lease, every variation and any other document tied to the premises, then fix the last day for exercise from them.
    2. Under a retail shop lease with a market rent review on renewal, check whether the s 27A early determination window is still open, because it closes well before the option date.
    3. At least three weeks before the last day and earlier where that day falls over the Christmas closures, get the notice and the way it will be served checked against the option and notices clauses.
    4. After service, watch for a breach notice from the landlord, because the time to apply for relief runs from it and is short.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    My landlord never reminded me about the option date. Do I get more time?

    The Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld) gives none. A retail shop landlord that fails to give the notice commits an offence, but in Queensland that failure leaves the option date where the lease puts it and any argument for more time on that ground rests on what the landlord said or did.

    I am behind on rent. Can I still exercise the option?

    You can give the notice, but if the option is conditional on the tenant not being in breach, unpaid rent can defeat it, as it did in Replay, a case decided under the earlier Act. Under the Property Law Act 2023 (Qld), even for a lease signed before that Act commenced, a landlord that wants to refuse renewal because of the breach must give a Form 8 breach notice within 10 business days after receiving your notice or after a later breach and you then have one month to seek relief.

    I sold my shares in the tenant company. Am I still a guarantor?

    A share sale does not of itself end a guarantee of the company's lease, so unless the landlord released you, you may still be a guarantor when the company exercises its option.

    Sources and References

    Share

    This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied on as such. While we take reasonable care to ensure the accuracy of the information provided, we make no representations or warranties as to its completeness, currency or reliability. We accept no liability for any loss or damage arising directly or indirectly from the use of or reliance on, this website's content. You should always seek professional advice tailored to your specific circumstances before acting on any information in this article. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

    Related Practice Area

    Property

    Option date coming up?

    Two leases with the same option date can call for different notices, signed by different people and served in different ways. Jamie Nuich will look over yours alongside the lease.

    Related Articles

    Cookies on by default ·Privacy