I'm Being Removed From the Board
How a director of a private company is removed is decided by the company's constitution, read with any shareholders agreement, rather than by the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) on its own. The Corporations Act's removal rule for proprietary companies, s 203C, is a replaceable rule, so a constitution can rewrite it, hand the power to the board or a particular shareholder or attach conditions to it. In a public company the members can remove a director under s 203D whatever the constitution says, after giving the company notice of intention, ordinarily two months before the meeting. And a removal that is valid on paper can still ground an oppression claim under s 232 where it shuts a shareholder out of the management or the returns they came into the company expecting to share. Astris Law in Brisbane starts by working out which of those three positions a director is in.
A resolution to remove you may arrive in a notice of meeting, sometimes tacked onto a meeting already called. The exclusion can also be quieter, with board papers that stop coming and decisions made in conversations you are not part of. In a company two directors hold between them, a disagreement can stall the business without anyone being removed. A board or majority seeking a director's removal works under the same rules from the other side.
Once a notice of meeting is out, a proprietary company needs only 21 days' notice of a members' meeting unless its constitution requires more and a s 203C removal needs no advance notice of intention. That leaves about three weeks to read the documents, test the notice, secure your records and put your position in writing. A director who holds no shares may not get a notice at all, because the members can remove them by a resolution they all sign.
What You Need To Know
In a proprietary company, s 203C of the Corporations Act lets the members remove a director by resolution and appoint another in their place, but it is a replaceable rule and a constitution that sets its own removal procedure or gives the board a removal power displaces it. If the members vote at a meeting, the only statutory notice period is the 21 days' notice of the meeting under s 249H, which members holding at least 95 per cent of the votes that may be cast can shorten by agreeing beforehand or all members if the meeting is an annual general meeting. A meeting is not always needed, because a resolution signed by every member entitled to vote passes under s 249A without one, so a director who holds no shares can be removed without notice.
A public company director can be removed by resolution only by the members under s 203D, which applies despite anything in the constitution or in any agreement between the company or its members and the director and the directors cannot do it themselves because s 203E makes such a resolution void. Notice of intention to move the resolution must reach the company at least two months before the meeting, unless the company itself calls the meeting after receiving it.
Section 232 lets a court intervene where the conduct of a company's affairs, an actual or proposed act or omission by or on behalf of the company or a resolution or proposed resolution of members is either contrary to the interests of the members as a whole or oppressive to, unfairly prejudicial to or unfairly discriminatory against a member, whether in that capacity or in any other capacity. The applicant must ordinarily be a member or a former member in the circumstances s 234 describes, so a director who has never held shares in their own name does not have this remedy.
A current director can inspect the company's financial records at all reasonable times under s 290 and a current or former director can inspect the books under s 198F for a legal proceeding they are a party to, propose in good faith to bring or have reason to believe will be brought against them. A shareholder can apply for an inspection order under s 247A.
The company must notify the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) within 28 days whether a director resigns or is removed and a resignation notified late takes effect from lodgement under s 203AA unless ASIC or a court later fixes the earlier date on application. A director penalty for the company's unpaid tax or superannuation that has already arisen stays with you either way and so does the s 183 prohibition on misusing information gained as a director, which continues after you go.
What To Do Before the Meeting
Get the constitution, any shareholders agreement and the registers
Ask the company for its constitution or confirm that it has none and runs on the replaceable rules. Pull the current company extract from ASIC and, if you have access, the register of members and the minute book. The constitution, read with any shareholders agreement, decides whether the removal is available by the route being used.
Check the notice, the quorum and who can vote
The notice period, any consent to short notice, the quorum and who was entitled to notice and to vote all go to whether the meeting is valid and in a public company so do the date the notice of intention reached the company and who called the meeting. Under s 1322 a defect in notice or the absence of a quorum invalidates the meeting only where the court finds it has caused or may cause substantial injustice that no other order can fix.
Secure the information and records you are entitled to
While you are a director, use your right of access to the financial records under s 290 and keep the board papers and minutes you have received in the ordinary course. If you propose in good faith to bring proceedings or have reason to believe they will be brought against you, s 198F lets you inspect the other books for that proceeding and copy them for it. Keep your own dated notes of what was said and decided. Take only what you are entitled to and use it only for the dispute and the company's affairs, because s 183 prohibits the improper use of information obtained as a director and a breach gives the company, which the majority controls, a claim against you.
Put your position in writing before the meeting
In a public company the written statement under s 203D is circulated to members with the notice if there is time. In a proprietary company there is no statutory right to be heard, but a letter to the company before the vote can put an objection on record. Every sentence of that letter can later be read by the other side and possibly by a judge.
Think about an injunction only where the material supports it
Under s 1324 a person whose interests are affected by a contravention of the Corporations Act can ask the court to restrain it, which is the route where the meeting itself breaks a provision of that Act, such as the notice rules or s 203D. A removal that breaches only the constitution or a shareholders agreement is enforced as a matter of contract and a court asked to step in before a meeting will want to know what the order preserves that a later order could not restore. An application built on a bare technical defect has s 1322 in its way.
Weigh the s 232 route against a negotiated exit
If you hold shares, the choice is between an oppression application, which can end in an order that the others buy your shares at a value set by the court and a negotiated sale under whatever exit mechanics the shareholders agreement contains. If you hold no shares, the realistic questions are your contract, your records and the liabilities that survive your departure.
How Removal Works by Company Type
A proprietary company with no constitution runs on the replaceable rules, so s 203C applies as written. A proprietary company with a constitution follows the constitution, which may require a special majority, a longer notice period or a particular procedure, give the board power to remove a director by majority vote or attach each board seat to a shareholder or class who alone can appoint and remove that director. Read the clause before assuming the members' vote in s 203C is available, because where the constitution is inconsistent with a replaceable rule the constitution prevails. A members' resolution that would leave a proprietary company with no director does not take effect, so in a sole-director company the removal and the appointment of a replacement have to be done together.
A shareholders agreement sits alongside the constitution and binds the shareholders who signed it. If it reserves board seats to particular shareholders or lists the removal of a director as a matter needing unanimity or a special majority, a removal pushed through by a bare majority may be valid under the constitution yet still a breach of the agreement. The two documents are often out of step because one was amended and the other was not.
In a public company the two months' notice of intention to the company under s 203D runs alongside the notice of the meeting itself under s 249H, which is 21 days (28 for a listed company) with no short notice permitted for that resolution. The director is entitled to a copy of the notice of intention as soon as practicable, to have a written statement circulated to members and to speak to the motion at the meeting whether or not they are a member.
Forcing a Meeting and Getting the Books
Where the board will not call the meeting, members holding at least 5 per cent of the votes that may be cast can require it under s 249D by a signed written request given to the company that states any resolution to be proposed. The directors must call the meeting within 21 days and hold it within two months. If they do not, members with more than half the votes of those who made the request can call it themselves under s 249E and the company must pay the reasonable expenses they incur because the directors did not act. Under s 249F members with 5 per cent can call a meeting at any time at their own expense.
The s 198F right of a current director covers the books other than the financial records, which s 290 already opens to them and it is confined to the purposes of a legal proceeding they are party to, propose in good faith to bring or have reason to believe will be brought against them. A former director keeps the s 198F right for seven years and for them it extends to the financial records. A shareholder who is not a director has no automatic right and can apply for an order under s 247A, satisfying the court that they are acting in good faith and that the inspection is for a proper purpose, which the cases read as one connected with their interests as a shareholder.
When a Removal Becomes Oppression
Under s 232 a resolution of members can be oppressive, unfairly prejudicial or unfairly discriminatory even where every procedural step was followed, because the removal is tested against its effect on the member rather than against whether the paperwork was in order. That matters most in a small company run as a partnership in corporate form, where each shareholder came in on the understanding that they would sit on the board and share in running the business. In Fexuto Pty Ltd v Bosnjak Holdings Pty Ltd (2001) 37 ACSR 672 a minority shareholder in a family bus business had been progressively shut out of decision making by the majority and the exclusion was found to be oppressive although the majority had acted within its formal powers.
In Wayde v New South Wales Rugby League Ltd (1985) 180 CLR 459 Brennan J put the test objectively: whether reasonable directors, with the knowledge the actual directors had and weighing the company's object against the burden on the member, would have regarded the decision as unfair. The exclusion of a club from the competition in that case was prejudicial and discriminatory but not shown to be unfair, so the complaint failed. A removal that disadvantages you is not of itself oppression.
A claim of that kind is built on the understanding on which the company was set up and run and on when the conduct departed from it, so the evidence usually reaches back years before the dispute began.
What a Court Can Order
Under s 233 the court may make any order it considers appropriate and the section lists examples: winding the company up, modifying or repealing the constitution, regulating the conduct of the company's affairs in the future, ordering the purchase of a member's shares by another member or by the company with a matching reduction of capital, requiring the company to bring or defend proceedings or authorising a member to do so in its name, appointing a receiver, restraining a person from specified conduct and requiring a person to do a specified act.
Where one side is ordered to buy the other's shares, the valuation becomes the contest: the date at which the shares are valued, whether a minority discount applies and how diverted business or excessive remuneration is brought back into the figure. Winding up sits on the list too and the separate just and equitable ground in s 461(1)(k) remains available, although s 467(4) lets the court refuse that order where another remedy, such as a buy-out, is available and the applicants are acting unreasonably in seeking to have the company wound up instead of pursuing it.
In Queensland an oppression application is filed in the Trial Division of the Supreme Court of Queensland in Brisbane, where a substantial commercial dispute can be placed on the Commercial List under Practice Direction 1 of 2023 or in the Queensland Registry of the Federal Court of Australia, since s 1337B gives both courts jurisdiction under the Corporations Act. The orders are discretionary and shaped to the company in front of the court, so the list of powers says little about the order a court would make in your case and gauging that is the first piece of work on any application.
Removing a Director From a Licensed or Registered Company
Under s 173 of the Education and Care Services National Law (Queensland) and the Education and Care Services National Regulations, the approved provider of a childcare service must tell the Regulatory Authority, which for a Queensland service is the Director-General of the Department of Education acting through the Early Childhood Regulatory Authority, within 14 days of the appointment or removal of a person with management or control of the service. The definition lists an officer of a corporate provider and also reaches anyone else with authority or significant influence over the service. Where the majority's case for removal goes to the director's fitness and propriety, duties to give notice within 7 days can apply as well. One is the duty under the A New Tax System (Family Assistance) (Administration) Act 1999 (Cth) of a provider approved for the Child Care Subsidy to tell the Commonwealth Department of Education within 7 days of becoming aware of a circumstance suggesting that a person with management or control may no longer be fit and proper.
A company's contractor's licence from the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) depends on a nominee, who must be a director, secretary or employee of the company and hold a licence of the same class and the QBCC says a change of director is to be notified within 14 days. If the director being removed is also the nominee and holds no other role in the company, the removal can leave the company without a nominee and the QBCC says a company has 14 days to tell it when its nominee stops acting and 28 days to replace them or its licence may be suspended or cancelled. A director appointed in a hurry to the vacant seat brings their own history, because the excluded individual rules in the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) can put the licence at risk where a new director has been through a bankruptcy event or was a director of a construction company that went into liquidation, in each case within the periods that statute sets.
The director being voted off the board of an Australian financial services licensee may also be the responsible manager named as a key person on its licence. If they leave the business as well as the board, ASIC says the licensee must notify it within 5 business days of the actions it will take to replace that key person and that the variation which follows may take up to three months.
For a registered National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) provider, the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission says the provider's key personnel can include every member of its board and that telling it of a change in them is a requirement of registration. The National Disability Insurance Scheme (Provider Registration and Practice Standards) Rules 2018 (Cth) also require separate notice, as soon as practicable, of an event bearing on a key person's suitability.
How We Can Help
Astris Law acts for directors and shareholders of private companies in board disputes, whether the client is the director facing removal or the board that wants a director to go. Jamie Nuich reads the constitution, the shareholders agreement and the notice with you and says whether the resolution can be passed by the route proposed, what notice and voting rules apply and where the documents leave room to argue. That reading also covers what the removal sets running with a regulator if the company is licensed or registered. For a shareholder being shut out, the questions are the history of participation and the understanding on which the company was set up, which is the evidence an oppression claim rests on and whether a negotiated exit serves you better. For a majority that wants a director gone, the question is whether the constitution has been followed to the letter, because a departure from it is usually where the departing director's claim comes from. Astris Law also drafts constitutions and shareholders agreements that deal with removal, deadlock and exit in terms.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the other directors remove me from the board?
In a proprietary company, only if the constitution gives the board that power. Otherwise removal is for the members, under s 203C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) or under whatever procedure the constitution substitutes for it. In a public company the directors never can: s 203E makes void any resolution, request or notice of the directors that purports to remove a director or require one to vacate office and only the members acting under s 203D can do it.
How much notice do I get before a vote to remove me as a director?
For a proprietary company, if the members vote at a meeting the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) requires only notice of the meeting, which is 21 days under s 249H unless the constitution sets a longer period and members holding at least 95 per cent of the votes can agree beforehand to less. There is no advance notice of intention unless the constitution adds one. If every member entitled to vote signs a resolution under s 249A no meeting is held, so a director who holds no shares may receive no notice at all. For a public company, notice of intention must be given to the company at least two months before the meeting, although if the company calls the meeting after receiving it the meeting can be held inside that period and the meeting itself needs at least 21 days' notice or 28 for a listed company, with no short notice allowed.
Can I be removed as a director if I am also a shareholder?
Yes. Holding shares does not prevent the members from removing you as a director and the removal does not of itself affect your shares. Check the shareholders agreement and the constitution for a clause that treats ceasing to be a director as a leaver event, because those clauses can force a sale of your shares at a value fixed by a formula. The shareholding gives you standing to apply under s 232 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) if the removal or the conduct around it, is oppressive, unfairly prejudicial or unfairly discriminatory. You can also seek a court order to inspect the company's books under s 247A. If your shares are held through a family trust, the member is the trustee and these rights are the trustee's rather than yours. A removal that shuts out a shareholder who invested on the footing that they would help run the company is the kind of case in which oppression has been found.
Should I resign before they remove me?
Resigning is your own act, which you can notify to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) yourself, but it is not always the better course. In a public company it gives up the right to have your statement circulated and to speak at the meeting. It does not shed liabilities that have already arisen, including any director penalty for the company's unpaid tax and superannuation. Under s 203AA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) it takes effect from your resignation date if ASIC is told within 28 days and otherwise from the day the notice is lodged, unless an earlier date is fixed on application. Under s 203AB a resignation that would leave the company with no director does not take effect unless a replacement is appointed by that day. Resigning does not of itself affect your shares or your rights as a member, subject to any leaver clause in the shareholders agreement. The choice has to be made before the members act, because once they have passed the resolution there is no office left to resign.
What happens when two directors are deadlocked?
Under the replaceable rule in s 248G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) a directors' resolution passes by a majority of the votes cast and the chair has a casting vote if one is needed. Where a two-director company has no chair or the constitution removes the casting vote, a one-all split is a true deadlock. A shareholders agreement may already contain a deadlock clause or exit options and an exit option can end with one shareholder bound to sell to the other. Where nothing of that kind exists and the shareholders are split the same way, the just and equitable ground for winding up in s 461(1)(k) is open to either side and a company that is still profitable is not beyond its reach. An oppression order under s 233, such as a buy-out, needs conduct of the kind s 232 describes and a deadlock on its own is not that.
In a proprietary company the meeting can be held 21 days after the notice or sooner if members with at least 95 per cent of the votes agree and a resolution every member signs needs no meeting at all.
Don't wait until your options narrow.
Whether you are the director named in a removal resolution or among those proposing it, the number for Jamie Nuich is (07) 3519 5616. The first call begins with whatever notice or resolution has reached you, the constitution and any shareholders agreement, so keep all three within reach.